What to Expect When Working with a Landlord-Tenant Lawyer in NYC

Why People Hire Landlord-Tenant Lawyers in NYC

New York has one of the most intricate housing law systems in the country. And while not every dispute requires a lawyer, many situations do. Here’s when clients typically reach out to us:

• A tenant receives an eviction notice—especially in a rent-stabilized apartment
• A landlord needs to evict a non-paying or non-compliant tenant legally
• There’s a dispute over security deposits, illegal rent increases, or lease terms
• Tenants are living in uninhabitable conditions and the landlord won’t act
• Landlords are being accused of harassment or improper notice

Whether you’re a tenant defending your home or a landlord protecting your property, getting advice from a qualified landlord-tenant lawyer in NYC ensures you understand your rights and avoid costly missteps.

Step 1: The Free Consultation

At The Price Law Firm, your case starts with a free initial consultation. This is where we:

• Review the key facts of your situation
• Ask for important documents (e.g., lease, court papers, notices)
• Identify whether you’re dealing with a legal issue or a strategic problem
• Provide an honest assessment of your options

We understand the urgency of these disputes, so we aim to offer actionable feedback from the very first meeting. Whether you ultimately retain our firm or not, the consultation helps you make an informed decision.

Start your free case review here.

Step 2: Case Evaluation and Strategy Planning

Once you decide to move forward, we dive deeper into your case. This involves:

• Analyzing your lease and relevant housing laws
• Identifying your strongest legal positions and any vulnerabilities
• Discussing possible court venues (Housing Court, Civil Court, etc.)
• Outlining a strategy—litigation, negotiation, or both

At this stage, you’ll get a clear roadmap. We’ll walk you through what to expect at each step of the process and prepare you for likely scenarios. No legal jargon. Just facts and next steps.

Step 3: Legal Action or Defense

Depending on your case, we’ll either:

• File a case against the opposing party, or
• Respond to legal action already underway

For Tenants:

We help you:

• Respond to or challenge eviction notices
• File claims for harassment, neglect, or security deposit violations
• Demand repairs or legal compliance from your landlord

For Landlords:

We help you:

• Serve proper legal notices
• File holdover or nonpayment eviction proceedings
• Comply with NYC housing law while protecting your rights

Our team handles the paperwork, deadlines, and filings so you can focus on what matters: securing your home or managing your property.

Need to file or respond to an eviction case? Talk to a landlord-tenant attorney today.

Step 4: Representation in Court or Settlement Negotiations

Some cases resolve outside the courtroom, especially when both parties are open to negotiation. But if it does go to court, your lawyer’s role becomes even more critical.

We represent you in:

• Housing Court (for possession or rent issues)
• Civil Court (for money damages or lease enforcement)
• Supreme Court (for more complex or high-value disputes)

You don’t have to navigate Housing Court chaos on your own. We appear with you, argue your case, present your documentation, and fight for your rights in front of the judge. If the best route is a settlement, we’ll make sure the terms protect your interests—not just short-term, but long-term.

Step 5: Post-Resolution Support

Even after a case ends, landlord-tenant issues can continue. That’s why we provide ongoing support where needed.

This might include:

• Enforcing the judgment or court order
• Advising on lease renewals or modifications
• Responding to future legal threats
• Helping you avoid repeat conflicts

At The Price Law Firm, we’re not just here for the courtroom. We’re here to help you move forward with confidence, knowing your rights are protected.

Benefits of Hiring a Landlord-Tenant Lawyer

Still unsure if hiring a lawyer is worth it? Here’s what our clients say they value most after working with us:

1. Clarity

Landlord-tenant law in NYC is notoriously confusing. We cut through the legal language and tell you exactly where you stand and what your next move should be.

2. Strategy

Every case is different. We tailor our approach based on your goals—whether it’s staying in your home, removing a tenant, or settling quietly.

3. Courtroom Experience

We’ve litigated hundreds of landlord-tenant cases in New York. We know the judges, procedures, and most importantly—how to win.

4. Protection

Having an attorney ensures your rights are fully protected. From notice requirements to trial evidence, we help you avoid legal landmines.

5. Peace of Mind

You don’t have to carry the stress of doing this alone. We take the lead so you can focus on getting back to your life or managing your property.

Ready to hire a lawyer who knows NYC landlord-tenant law inside and out? Reach out now.

Real Client Scenarios We’ve Handled

Here are a few examples of real-world issues we’ve helped clients resolve:

• Tenant facing eviction in a rent-stabilized apartment after asserting repair needs. We proved retaliation and secured a settlement to keep them in the unit.
• Landlord dealing with a non-paying tenant who hadn’t paid rent in eight months. We filed a nonpayment proceeding and recovered possession legally.
• Tenant denied security deposit despite no damages. We filed a claim and recovered 1.5x the original deposit through court.
• Landlord accused of harassment, facing major legal penalties. We successfully defended against the claims with documentation and witness testimony.

Whatever your issue, there’s a legal path forward—and we’re here to help you find it.

FAQs About Working with a Landlord-Tenant Lawyer

How much does a landlord-tenant lawyer cost?

Cost depends on the complexity of the case. The Price Law Firm offers a free initial consultation to evaluate your situation and provide a clear estimate.

Is it worth hiring a lawyer for a small case?

Yes—especially if your housing or income is at stake. Even “small” cases can become serious if not handled correctly.

Can I switch lawyers if my current one isn’t helping?

Absolutely. You have the right to choose your representation. We regularly take over cases from clients dissatisfied with less focused firms.

How long will the case take?

This varies. Some matters settle in a few weeks; others may involve multiple court dates. Our goal is always to resolve the case as quickly and favorably as possible.

When Should You Call a Lawyer?

If you're asking the question, chances are it’s time. Landlord-tenant issues move fast in NYC—and waiting too long can weaken your position.

Here are some clear signals it’s time to contact a lawyer:

• You’ve received court papers or a notice to vacate
• Your landlord is entering your apartment illegally
• Your tenant has stopped paying rent or broken the lease
• You’re unsure how to handle a rent-stabilized property
• You feel overwhelmed by legal documents, deadlines, or procedures

Don't try to figure it out alone. One conversation with an experienced attorney can clarify your entire situation.

Contact The Price Law Firm Today

At The Price Law Firm, we bring over two decades of NYC-specific real estate litigation experience to your side. Whether you're a tenant fighting to stay in your home or a landlord trying to manage a tough situation, we know what it takes to resolve your dispute and protect your interests.

✅ Free consultation
✅ Tailored legal strategy
✅ Aggressive, experienced representation

🟩 Don’t Wait Until It’s Too Late

Every day matters in landlord-tenant disputes. Schedule your free case review now and take control of your situation with a legal team that understands NYC housing law inside and out.