Rent Too Damn High So McMillan Moved to Brooklyn?

Rent Too Damn High So McMillan Moved to Brooklyn?

Joshua Price • January 29, 2015

The rent may be “too damn high” but that’s not entirely the reason why Jimmy McMillan may be out of a rent-stabilized Manhattan apartment.

The New York Daily News reports the 2010 gubernatorial candidate was served with an eviction notice “ordering him out of his $872-a-month rent stabilized East Village apartment.”

Did Jimmy McMillan Move to Brooklyn?

We all know how McMillan felt about the cost of living in Manhattan but non-payment does not appear to be the only issue at hand. Rather, McMillan’s landlord claims the apartment in question is not McMillan’s primary residence and that he actually lives in Brooklyn.

One obligation of a rent stabilized tenancy is that the tenant actually lives in the subject apartment.

Jimmy’s Rent vs. Fair Market Value = Not Too Shabby

But Jimmy isn’t paying the rent. According to the Daily News:

McMillan insists there’s no beef over the rent tab — in fact, the landlord had repeatedly refused to accept his rent check because, he claims, they’re trying to get rid of low-paying tenants like him so they could rent the place out for much more money.”

He is in a rent stabilized apartment paying $872/month when the fair market value is about $3000/month. Despite that he isn’t paying the rent. The rent isn’t too damn high – it’s too bad he doesn’t pay it.

Fortunately for McMillan, who has filed suit to delay the holdover proceeding , it is his landlord who will bear the burden of proving the rent-stabilized apartment is not McMillan’s primary residence.

Don’t leave your legal matters to chance. SCHEDULE A CONSULTATION OR CALL US AT (212) 675-1125 for a personalized consultation and let our experts guide you through every step of the process.

Joshua Clinton Price

Founder of The Price Law Firm LLC

Josh Price is a lawyer who is sought by clients with complicated cases because of his extensive knowledge of the law and his ability to help the law evolve.

(212) 675-1125

Search an article



Contact Us for a
FREE Consultation

Blog (Website Form)

Price Law Firm - Gavel
Price Law Firm - Law Design Divider

Facing a real estate issue?

Contact us to schedule a consultation and get expert legal advice tailored to your specific needs and circumstances.

CONTACT OUR TEAM

OR CALL US NOW AT:

(212) 675-1125

SHARE THIS ARTICLE:

Recent Posts



landlord tenant lawyer
June 10, 2025
Learn what to expect when working with a landlord-tenant lawyer in NYC. The Price Law Firm provides experienced legal help for tenants and landlords. Free consultation available.
A man and woman are shaking hands with a landlord tenant lawyer in a suit while sitting on a couch.
June 10, 2025
Need legal help with a landlord-tenant dispute in New York City? The Price Law Firm, LLC offers aggressive, experienced representation for both tenants and landlords. Schedule a free consultation today.
A judge is writing on a piece of paper next to a gavel on a wooden table.
May 21, 2025
Avoiding legal mistakes as a landlord or tenant in NYC starts with hiring a landlord tenant attorney. Learn how Price Law Firm helps prevent disputes before they begin.
A book titled landlord-tenant law is on a wooden table next to a gavel and keys.
May 21, 2025
Wondering when to hire a landlord tenant attorney in NYC? Learn the key situations that call for legal help—and how Price Law Firm can help protect your rights.
A row of washing machines are lined up in a laundromat.
By John M. Churneftsky, Esq. April 22, 2025
Buying a laundromat in New York? Learn the legal due diligence steps—zoning, violations, permits, and more—from The Price Law Firm LLC before you close.
A laundromat with a cart in the middle of it
By John M. Churneftsky, Esq. April 22, 2025
Learn how landlord-lender agreements support laundromat financing by protecting equipment rights and reducing risk. The Price Law Firm LLC explains it all.

Get Expert Legal Advice

CALL US NOW
A white triangle on a blue background with a gold border.